Ape_man (here we are again, how is your HX year so far?), I read you 2 posts. Good stuff. Strong guts. (You've just made yourself an alter ego: Hater_Guest ... lucky you)
I do agree with you that a lot of Haitians have developped that universal animosity for a lot of countries. Especially the DR. Haitians are indeed figthing with principles and new education to reverse that hating trend laid dormant in the depths of their conscience since almost 2 centuries. Bad news about the DR does make a lot of Haitians feel better. It's sad, it's not true for everyone but it is the reality for most Haitians.
The reason is simple and understandable. Haitians align themselves with communities or nations who doesn't tolerate emperialism on whichever form. Because Haitians "BELIEVE" (not necessarily true) that the DR is too malleable by the US, the Haitian anti-imperialistic war takes the form of anti-Dominicanism. So the failing of anything in the DR is a recomfort for Haitians to prove themselves right once again: there's no lasting good in being friends with emprialistic monsters.
Nonetheless, I don't think Haiti's problems have turned them into haters. Ape_man, you are pushing and cracking the envelope here. It's better to understand than to judge because when judging prior to lucid analysis, it's easy to become myopic or blind about the truth.
Haitians have never revered politically Martinique, Guadeloupe and the other French overseas department in the Caribbean. But that doesn't mean they hate them. Haitians simply can't understand why a sovereign nation will voluntarily accept to be colonized by a superpower and go on with life as if everything is okay.
That's the overwheling Haitian political mentality. Whether that has served us to our peril or salvation, that's the mentality Haitians have ingrained in them from the womb of their mothers. They need not be scholarized or educated about it. They're born with that rebel and independent-from-the-superpowers fire.
Another example - Haitians see no hero in Martin Luther King. Freedom can't be asked for as a favor. That's why Blacks in the US are still being cornered whereever the Whites want them to be. Affirmative actions and all the alikes are very disrespectful but effective ways to quiet a whole race down. It's not freedom. It's silence through consolating gifts.
However, Haitians are very revering of Malcom X because the latter share the same combat rhetorics and principles as they. And it is of no surprise that Malcom X wanted the Black Americans to learn about Haiti's history, especially about Toussaint Louverture, rather than their own black role models in the present and the past. That's the foundation of the weak link between Haitians and "Afro-Americans" today. If the latter were delivered the Malcom X way, I guarantee that the link would be so strong that Blacks in general would be in much better political and economic position in the US.
A more vivid example that Haitians are not haters because of their unfortunate situation: CUBA! Here again, if you are UNDERSTANDING the concept of our nation, you will see that we tend to love anybody who doesn't fall in love with the starred beast. I KNOW for a fact that a lot of Haitians WISH they were Cubans. And some are even more Cubans than Haitians. Several Haitians have moved to Cuba to enjoy what they dream of their country. Haitians love Cuba in ways that no nation has ever loved any other nation in history because Cuba represents what we should be in the face of the starred crocodile.
And the list can go on about Venezuela, Che Guevara in all South America, Salvador in Guatemale, Allende in Chile, Sandino in Nicaragua, Patrice Lumumba in Africa, North Vietnam, Russia (once upon a time), etc... The motive for being on the side of or apart from a nation is simple for Haitians: the behavior of that nation vis-à-vis the US. Haitians are not haters, they are only revering those with the same fighting principles as theirs and want no good for the others so their point can be proven true.
And I know Kreyolbro enough to say that he didn't post those news because he hates the DR. The reasons he said he posted are truly the reasons. And Ape_man, you seem to forget that ONLY BAD NEWS IS NEWS. What you said about Haitians posting good news about the DR is pure absurdity. If you look at a lot of threads by Kreyolbro and Heleze since 2 months, they all start with a lot of BAD NEWS about Haiti. Do you think they posted them because they know Haitians on HX would feel good since Haitians have grown to be self-haters?
Come on, Ape-Man, you have valid points but you need to think twice before you draw the sword! Kreyolbro is right, we need to educate ourselves with the examples of infant-democracies so we know how to handle situations like the DR's. It will happen to us if we ever get onto the true democartic road.
Thank you Amber for understanding that also.
----------------- Tibob de Nazareth (http://tibobintroduction.012webpages.com/tibob0main.html )
Finding balance between the heart and the mind |